Page 1 of 1

Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2019 5:02 pm
by Richardb02
Score: Neutral
Parter: Average
You: Seat 4
Up: (Card_J-H)
Your hand: (Card_9-D) (Card_10-D) (Card_Q-S) (Card_Q-H) (Card_K-H)
Everyone passes around to you. Your decision?

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2019 6:33 pm
by Suz
I would call hearts

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2019 7:50 pm
by irishwolf
why would you consider passing?

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2019 8:05 pm
by Richardb02
There is a 3rd option. I suggest that a systematic and quantitative approach, would naturally lead you to the 3rd option. What do you suggest as the best decision?

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2019 9:11 pm
by Wes (aka the legend)
Richardb02 wrote:
Fri Mar 01, 2019 8:05 pm
There is a 3rd option. I suggest that a systematic and quantitative approach, would naturally lead you to the 3rd option. What do you suggest as the best decision?
You're overthinking this Richard. At a neutral score there is only one option. Call hearts. If down 9-6 then yes go alone. Hail mary time.

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Sat Mar 02, 2019 1:50 am
by RedDuke
Pick up the right, discard the queen of spades. That's really the only decision. As Wes says, you could try this as a loner if you need the points. It's not really a strong loner, but if your opponents are holding mostly black cards, it could work.

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Sat Mar 02, 2019 3:49 pm
by Richardb02
I evaluated my hand as a marginal Loner. BTW, I appreciate all y’all guidance on these marginal hands. I add an evaluation of being euchred if I go alone. I don’t mind losing 10-15% of the time when going alone. I felt that I had an 85% chance of making 1. So I went alone.

The hand went better than I envisioned. I trumped the 1st trick with Qh, drew trump with Jh (Jd fell, Ah in the wild), the Td walked, Kh walked, 9d walked. 4 points! Lucky of course but it worked. If Td fell, I still expected a good shot with the Kh winning and then the 9d (next) taking the last trick. I’ve had success with this approach but getting euchre 15% of the isn’t for the faint of heart

The big X factor is the level of competition. Experienced players are probably quoting experiences based on a higher level of opponents. So I understand why picking up is the favored recommendation. My approach may be working because of weak competition. That’s why I ask these questions.

I also want to ask about the psyche of being euchred. Euchre is a game of chance. I sense everyone agrees we must take a chance to maximize winning. Is there a chance we avoid being euchred, even if our best analysis suggests that we would gain net points by bidding more aggressively?

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Sun Mar 03, 2019 9:05 am
by RedDuke
I also want to ask about the psyche of being euchred. Euchre is a game of chance. I sense everyone agrees we must take a chance to maximize winning. Is there a chance we avoid being euchred, even if our best analysis suggests that we would gain net points by bidding more aggressively?
A lot of people do this. I've actually been euchred when I call and I'm holding four trump. I've had partners actually get very angry with me when this happens, even though mathematically the odds that you're going to get euchred if you're holding 4 (one of which is the right) is incredibly low.

There are times when the cards are just going to be against you. I once played a game against a guy that went alone holding

(Card_K-D) (Card_Q-D) (Card_10-D) (Card_9-D) (Card_A-C)

He got euchred because I was holding both red jacks and the ace of diamonds. Admittedly, while that hand was fairly unlikely to take all five tricks, the only way it's going to be euchred is if you have one opponent holding all three of the remaining trumps. That's a very low probability scenario. So really, his call was the correct one, but his partner started screaming and cussing him out over it.

In a lot of ways, I'd say that your partner's reaction to getting euchred is more likely to destroy your psyche than the euchre itself. If you see that your partner is getting angry, you might be less inclined to call on hands that could otherwise make a point if you aren't holding a sure thing. That could cost you the game.

If your call is a good one, just maintain your mental fortitude. If you've got a partner that has a clue what they're doing, they'll see the cards that you play and realize that it was a good call even if you get euchred.

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Sun Mar 03, 2019 10:54 am
by Dlan
If your call is a good one, just maintain your mental fortitude. If you've got a partner that has a clue what they're doing, they'll see the cards that you play and realize that it was a good call even if you get euchred.
Being a good partner requires a certain amount of discipline. All too often, I see one partner judging the other by what cards are in their hand. When one is euchred, the problem tends to be the fact that the hands either didn’t match up or weren’t played according to the other’s hand. Had your partner known you held the ace of hearts (clubs, spades or whatever) he surely would have led that. Or would have passed if they knew you had a lone, or…..

Re: Seat 4(Dealer) Decision

Posted: Sun Mar 03, 2019 11:45 am
by RedDuke
Dlan wrote:
Sun Mar 03, 2019 10:54 am
If your call is a good one, just maintain your mental fortitude. If you've got a partner that has a clue what they're doing, they'll see the cards that you play and realize that it was a good call even if you get euchred.
Being a good partner requires a certain amount of discipline. All too often, I see one partner judging the other by what cards are in their hand. When one is euchred, the problem tends to be the fact that the hands either didn’t match up or weren’t played according to the other’s hand. Had your partner known you held the ace of hearts (clubs, spades or whatever) he surely would have led that. Or would have passed if they knew you had a lone, or…..
You also have to learn to trust your partner sometimes. I can't tell you how many times I've gotten euchred because my partner trumped a trick that I would have otherwise taken, causing my ace to be wasted.